South African fraudulent construction

Uncovering South African fraudulent construction: Types, Impacts, and Solutions

SAPAC Reporter

South African Fraudulent Construction: A Threat to Safety and Trust

Uncovering the Hidden Dangers of Construction Fraud in South Africa

South Africa’s construction industry is a cornerstone of economic growth, driving infrastructure development and job creation. Yet, beneath its vital contributions lies a troubling issue: fraudulent practices that undermine safety, inflate costs, and erode public trust. From material substitution to tender rigging and extortion by so-called "construction mafias," fraud in this sector has far-reaching consequences. This article explores the common types of construction fraud, their impact, and how SAPAC are working to combat these challenges.

The Scale of the Problem

Fraud in South Africa’s construction industry is a pervasive issue, costing the economy billions and jeopardising public safety. According to the Council for the Built Environment (CBE), fraudulent practices such as cutting corners on materials or labour while charging for high-quality work lead to unsafe structures and costly repairs. The Special Investigating Unit (SIU) and the Department of Public Works have reported over 700 cases of construction site disruptions by criminal gangs since 2019, with projects worth R63 billion affected by extortion. These "construction mafias" demand a share of profits, often using violence or intimidation, further escalating costs and delays.

A 2024 report by the CBE highlights that fraudulent contractors often inflate project costs by submitting exaggerated budgets or overstating material and labour expenses, sometimes diverting funds into private accounts. Bribery is also rampant, particularly in government contracts, where public officials may accept kickbacks to award tenders or overlook substandard work. These practices not only drain public and private resources but also compromise the structural integrity of buildings and infrastructure.

Common Types of Construction Fraud

Fraud in South Africa’s construction sector takes many forms, each with devastating consequences. Here are the most prevalent types identified by industry experts:

  1. Substitution or Removal of Materials
    The South African Professionals and Contractors Collective (SAPAC) identifies material substitution as a primary concern. Contractors may use substandard materials while charging for premium ones, leading to hazardous structures that fail to meet safety standards. This practice not only defrauds clients but also exposes occupants to risks like structural collapse. Furthermore a concerning trend is the changes made to the JBCC Contracts, that are being allowed. 

  2. Falsification of Payment Applications and Invoices
    Over half of construction fraud involves manipulating payment applications. Contractors at any level of the payment chain may inflate costs or exaggerate work completion percentages to boost profits. Some pocket the difference by misrepresenting payments to subcontractors or suppliers, creating a ripple effect of financial misconduct.

  3. Tender Fraud and Bid Rigging
    Collusive bidding, or bid rigging, is a common scheme where contractors collude to manipulate tender outcomes. A 2013 case saw 15 major construction companies fined R1.4 billion for collusive tendering. False credentials or forged documents, as seen in the R15.3 million Talana housing project fraud in Limpopo, are also used to secure contracts dishonestly.

  4. Extortion by Construction Mafias
    Criminal syndicates, often posing as local "business forums," invade construction sites to demand a share of profits—typically 30%—using threats of violence. Since 2019, 712 cases have been reported, with 722 suspects arrested. These disruptions have cost the economy R68 billion and deter foreign investment, stunting infrastructure growth.

  5. Bribery and Corruption
    Bribery in public works contracts is widespread, with "officials" accepting payments to overlook regulatory violations or award tenders. A 2011 Bribe Payers Index noted the construction sector as particularly vulnerable, with corruption costing the state an estimated R10 billion in price-fixing alone.

The Impact of Construction Fraud

The consequences of construction fraud extend beyond financial losses. Shoddy workmanship resulting from material substitution or poor labour practices creates unsafe buildings, endangering lives. For example, a 2018 court case involving a "contractor" highlighted extensive damages to a truck yard’s concrete surface due to lack of diligence, underscoring the real-world risks of substandard work.

Economically, fraud deters investment and stalls development. The R63 billion in disrupted projects since 2019 has led to lost opportunities and the emigration of skilled professionals, depleting the sector’s expertise. Public trust in government and industry also suffers, as seen in high-profile cases like the Cape Town tender scandal involving alleged gang ties and a former official.

Combating Construction Fraud with SAPAC

The South African Professionals and Contractors Collective (SAPAC) is at the forefront of addressing these challenges. By connecting homeowners, businesses, and conveyance attorneys with registered, insured, and qualified professionals, SAPAC ensures transparency and accountability. Its rigorous pre-qualification process weeds out fraudulent contractors, requiring clear, standardized documentation to prevent misrepresentation.

SAPAC also educates stakeholders on red flags, such as consistently winning bids by the same contractor or unusually high bids from others, which may indicate bid rigging. By reserving the right to reject suspicious bids, clients can protect themselves from fraudulent schemes. Additionally, SAPAC collaborates with industry various bodies which offers a free, anonymous hotlines to report fraud and corruption.

Recent government efforts, including the Infrastructure Built Anti-Corruption Forum led by the SIU and Department of Public Works, have also made strides. Since November 2024, intensified intelligence and law enforcement operations have led to 30 cases referred to provincial authorities, with economic infrastructure task teams deployed to mafia hotspots.

How to Protect Yourself from Construction Fraud

Homeowners, businesses, and estate agents can take proactive steps to mitigate risks:

  • Verify Contractor Credentials: Use SAPAC to ensure contractors are registered and insured. Check their track record and references.
  • Demand Transparency: Require detailed, standardized bids and invoices. Be wary of vague documentation or last-minute cost increases.
  • Report Suspicious Activity: Use SAPAC’s platform to report suspected fraud anonymously or go directly to the NHBRC through their hotline at 0800 203 698
  • Monitor Projects Closely: Regular site inspections can catch material substitution or substandard work early.
  • Stay Informed: Understand common fraud tactics, such as bid rigging or invoice manipulation, to spot red flags.

Avoid these by contacting SAPAC before your project is undertaken. 

A Call for Collective Action

Construction fraud in South Africa is a multifaceted challenge that demands a united response. By leveraging SAPAC, and fostering transparency, stakeholders can rebuild trust and ensure safer, more reliable infrastructure. 

Ready to build with confidence? Connect with professionals through SAPAC at sapac.co.za and safeguard your project from fraud today.

Get in contact with SAPAC today! 

Terug naar blog